DOL Proposes Major Overhaul of PERM Labor Certification
What Happened
On November 16, 2026, the U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) announced a proposed rule to overhaul the Permanent Labor Certification (PERM) program, the first step in most employment-based green card cases. The proposed rule, "Modernizing the Labor Market Test and Improving Protections for U.S. Workers in the PERM Immigrant Visa Program," was published in the Federal Register on November 17, 2026 (91 FR 73916). DOL describes it as the first comprehensive set of PERM reforms in nearly 20 years. If finalized, it would change nearly every stage of the PERM process, from the prevailing wage request through I-140 approval.
What Is Changing
Under the current rules, employers test the U.S. labor market through a fixed set of print and supplemental recruitment steps and generally keep their recruitment documentation on file unless audited. The proposed rule would replace this framework with a modernized, more prescriptive process and new protections for U.S. workers. Key proposed changes include:
- Online Recruitment Replaces Print Ads. The two Sunday newspaper ads and the menu of additional steps for professional positions would be eliminated. All positions would require a state workforce agency (SWA) job order, an ad on the employer's website, an ad on at least one third-party job board, social media if the employer customarily uses it to recruit, and at least one job fair, on-campus recruiting event, or school placement office.
- Recruit the Way You Normally Hire. PERM recruitment would have to mirror the employer's ordinary recruitment for non-PERM positions, using the same websites, platforms, and methods. Recruitment through any channel less accessible to U.S. workers would be presumed not in good faith.
- 90-Day Minimum Advertising Period. Ads would have to run at least 90 calendar days, or longer if the employer customarily advertises similar jobs longer. Recruitment would have to end 30 to 60 days before filing, and the application would have to be filed within 30 days after recruitment ends.
- Recruitment Report Filed Up Front. Employers would file the recruitment report, every U.S. applicant's résumé, and proof of recruitment and notice of filing compliance with the application itself, rather than only on audit. The report would be far more detailed, including ad URLs and confirmation numbers, each applicant's disposition, and the employees who screened each applicant.
- Incomplete Applications Returned. An incomplete application would be returned without review, would lose its filing date, and could not be appealed.
- Closer Scrutiny of Job Requirements. DOL would compare the PERM job requirements with the employer's own non-PERM postings from the prior 12 months. Materially stricter requirements would need a business necessity justification.
- Schedule A Eliminated. Employers sponsoring nurses, physical therapists, and individuals of exceptional ability in the sciences or arts would have to complete full PERM recruitment and file with DOL. The special procedure for sheepherders would also end. Because the new rules would apply based on filing date, employers should file pending Schedule A cases promptly. Some positions may still avoid labor certification through other routes, such as a National Interest Waiver.
- Faculty Special Handling Retained, With Changes. Colleges and universities could still use the competitive recruitment and selection process for teaching positions, and the "more qualified" standard would remain. However, the current 18-month filing window would be replaced by a requirement to file within 30 days after recruitment ends, and recruitment documentation would be filed with the application.
- Two-Year Layoff Bar. Employers that laid off U.S. workers in the same or similar occupation in the area of intended employment within two years before filing could not file. The current lookback is six months.
- Post-Filing Layoff Obligations. Layoffs after filing would have to be reported to DOL, and to USCIS if an I-140 is pending, within five business days. The employer would have to offer the job to laid-off workers and update its recruitment report, and these obligations would continue until the I-140 is approved. Employers also could not place the sponsored worker with a client that has had similar layoffs.
- Extended Notice of Filing. The notice of filing would be posted within 10 business days before filing and remain up until the I-140 is approved, including at third-party worksites. Electronic posting would be permitted.
- Accountability for Representatives. DOL could debar attorneys, agents, and their successors in interest for their own misconduct, and debarment would extend across all DOL labor certification programs.
- Proposed Transition. DOL proposes a 60-day delayed effective date after the final rule is published, plus an additional 30-day transition. Applications would be governed by the rules in effect on their filing date, so applications filed within 29 days after the effective date would still be processed under the current rules. The proposed regulatory text uses placeholder dates (January 19 and February 16, 2027) that do not align with this 90-day transition and are expected to change in the final rule.
At a Glance
| Topic | Current Rules | Proposed Rule |
|---|---|---|
| Recruitment | SWA job order, two Sunday print ads, plus three of ten additional steps for professional positions | SWA job order, employer website, third-party job board, customary social media, and a job fair, campus event, or placement office |
| Advertising period | No minimum online duration; recruitment within 30 to 180 days before filing | At least 90 days, ending 30 to 60 days before filing; file within 30 days after recruitment ends |
| Documentation | Retained and produced only on audit | Recruitment report, résumés, and proof of compliance filed with the application |
| Schedule A | Nurses, physical therapists, and exceptional ability skip recruitment | Eliminated; full PERM recruitment required |
| Layoffs | Six-month lookback triggers notice and consideration | Two-year filing bar; post-filing reporting within five business days through I-140 approval |
| Notice of filing | 10 consecutive business days within 30 to 180 days before filing | Posted within 10 business days before filing and kept up through I-140 approval |
What This Means for Employers
This is a proposed rule only, and the current PERM rules remain in effect. If finalized as proposed, however, the rule would significantly lengthen PERM timelines and raise the compliance stakes for every sponsoring employer. The 90-day advertising minimum and tighter filing windows would add months to the process. Up-front filing of the recruitment report and applicant résumés would expose every case to substantive review, and an incomplete filing would cost the employer its filing date. Employers with any layoffs in the past two years, and health care employers that rely on Schedule A for nurses and physical therapists, would be the most directly affected. Employers whose PERM recruitment differs from their ordinary hiring practices should expect closer scrutiny.
What You Should Do Now
- Prioritize PERM cases for H-1B employees who will need an approved I-140 to extend beyond the six-year maximum. Longer recruitment timelines under the proposed rule could make it harder to file in time.
- Accelerate other pending and planned PERM cases, including Schedule A cases, where possible so recruitment and filing can be completed under the current rules.
- Review any layoffs in the past two years against planned sponsorships.
- Document your current non-PERM recruitment practices, which would become the baseline for PERM recruitment.
- Assess any reliance on Schedule A for nurse and physical therapist hiring and plan for longer timelines.
- Consider submitting comments, which are due by 11:59 p.m. ET on January 19, 2027, through regulations.gov under Docket No. ETA-2026-0133.
We Are Here to Help
The Koley Jessen Immigration Practice Group is closely monitoring this proposed rule and is prepared to assist employers in evaluating its impact on their sponsorship programs and in preparing comments. If you have questions about how this proposal may affect your organization, please do not hesitate to reach out to a member of our team.
This content is made available for educational purposes only and to give you general information and a general understanding of the law, not to provide specific legal advice. By using this content, you understand there is no attorney-client relationship between you and the publisher. The content should not be used as a substitute for competent legal advice from a licensed professional attorney in your state.